Questions from the Jury

Carrie White wrote:

Clear Rivers wrote:Carrie, which version of your movie do you like the most?

Riverdale musical episode! Lol Kidding

And there goes my vote


Lol jk

It’s still open

Tree Gelbman wrote:

Luba Gibbs wrote:Tree, also congrats to you on making the final 2. I really don’t know where we fully stood this whole game because I continued to get a vibe that you were just using me for information. So how much of our relationship was real, especially considering when I needed you most you turned your back on me after all the conversations we had.

Honestly thinking about it, I don’t know who I’m voting for since you both did me so dirty during my eviction.

Thank you Luba. So to address the using you for information. I was definitely not trying to do that or come across that way. I will admit that in the beginning of the game you were someone I viewed as very close to me and I wanted to go far with. Closer and closer to your eviction, I did not really know where you fully stood with me either. We had one of those relationships where it was like “are we good? are we not good? what is she thinking?” I’m sure you felt that too. After the Mindy vote though, I was ready to integrate you into the new group I was making to take on the really strong competitors of the house. Clear won that HOH though and with you and Samara as the final nominees, I ended up choosing Samara. With Samara I KNEW she would protect me and target the other side. With you, it was very open ended and I did not know for sure. I had to go with the sure thing over the 50/50 chance. I did tell you right away though that I would be evicting you. I did not want you to be someone that also felt strung along by me once my mind was made up. My words of encouragement for you to try and get some votes for yourself was genuine. If you stayed I would have tried to get closer with you like I was with Samara and work with you til the end game like I did with her. It just did not work out that way with how the week fell.

How can you say we weren’t close and you didn’t know where we stand after I had made multiple comments that I felt on the low totem pole and that it felt like you, myself, Carrie, and Samara vs everyone else yet still question the loyalty I had?

Thank you Luba! Truthfully, I knew that Samara and myself were in trouble that week. I was tired of feeling like I was about to be a nominee again so when you had told me what you said to Clear I was frustrated because I just didn’t want to be nominated again. I felt if I exposed you, it would make you the target, saving both Samara and myself. Thankfully, (and i’m sorry to say) that happened because Samara was my #1 ally so I needed a bigger target in Clear’s eyes for her to evict than us. It wasn’t anything personal, but I felt I needed to do so to stay. Also, I’m sorry that you were telling me the truth, but in this game perception is our own reality so the fact that I felt weary and that’s my own reality. It was nothing personal at all.

With the voting me out, yes I wanted to be voted out and I understand. Also, with leaving you on read after the vote, votes were always read in the morning when I was at work so I’m sorry about that, but had I been able to be on I would’ve been. I hope that clarifies and if it doesn’t let me know but just know I liked you as a person, but for the game I NEEDED someone to look like a bigger threat to Clear than me.

Luba Gibbs wrote:

Tree Gelbman wrote:

Luba Gibbs wrote:Tree, also congrats to you on making the final 2. I really don’t know where we fully stood this whole game because I continued to get a vibe that you were just using me for information. So how much of our relationship was real, especially considering when I needed you most you turned your back on me after all the conversations we had.

Honestly thinking about it, I don’t know who I’m voting for since you both did me so dirty during my eviction.

Thank you Luba. So to address the using you for information. I was definitely not trying to do that or come across that way. I will admit that in the beginning of the game you were someone I viewed as very close to me and I wanted to go far with. Closer and closer to your eviction, I did not really know where you fully stood with me either. We had one of those relationships where it was like “are we good? are we not good? what is she thinking?” I’m sure you felt that too. After the Mindy vote though, I was ready to integrate you into the new group I was making to take on the really strong competitors of the house. Clear won that HOH though and with you and Samara as the final nominees, I ended up choosing Samara. With Samara I KNEW she would protect me and target the other side. With you, it was very open ended and I did not know for sure. I had to go with the sure thing over the 50/50 chance. I did tell you right away though that I would be evicting you. I did not want you to be someone that also felt strung along by me once my mind was made up. My words of encouragement for you to try and get some votes for yourself was genuine. If you stayed I would have tried to get closer with you like I was with Samara and work with you til the end game like I did with her. It just did not work out that way with how the week fell.

How can you say we weren’t close and you didn’t know where we stand after I had made multiple comments that I felt on the low totem pole and that it felt like you, myself, Carrie, and Samara vs everyone else yet still question the loyalty I had?

So what I meant by is not being as close was around the end of my reign to the end of Sheila’s reign as HOH. So the start of week 4 to the end of week 6. I was not FULLY sure if you still had better connections than me. But when we specifically had those conversations about being low on the totem pole and you wanting to work with me, Carrie and Samara that is when I knew you were being sincere and would be totally loyal to me. Again though, it was too late for us because Clear ended up winning and had you and Samara on the block. I am sorry for questioning the loyalty throughout the middle of the game. You NEVER know in these things and you always have to have your guard up. But I am serious when I say had you survived that week you would have became way way higher on my list of close allies and I would have tried getting towards the end with you.

I have to get back. Tatum, Nancy, Mindy & Penelope I will address your statements/questions when I get home. And anyone else that has more. I will try to make them as thorough as possible in the time allotted.

Thank you ladies; I think I have made up my mind. Good luck to both of you

For Tatum:

1. What is your biggest weakness and what have you done to try and make up for it?

Not being as active as I’d hoped in the beginning of the season to the house. I was talking to people in one on ones, but I wanted to be more of a house presence but I wasn’t able to. I’ve made up by this by being a presence and truly being a presence to ALL. I 100% flipped my game around after Mindy’s eviction and for some that is hard to flip your game, which I am proud of my ability to do that.

2. What about your game makes it more of a winning game compared to your opponent? Why should YOU be the representation of BB Horror season 1?

I think my game is a winning game because I was able to survive votes, create positive relationships with lots of players, win competitions, and make it to the final 2. Now, opposed to Tree I feel my game should be the winner because Tree was more out there, but when you piss almost all of the jury off, there is something there that you didn’t do right. Very little houseguests left the house pissed directly at me, and I think that does say something about my game. Also, there was never one vote that I voted incorrectly on. I did have an idea of what was happening and was never on the wrong side of the vote.

3. Why do you think you deserve MY vote? Do you think you deserve a vote from ME specifically and why?

Tatum I do think I deserve your vote. I think you were a badass player in this game and I recognize that. You and I talked a lot more in the latter half and I feel that I never did anything too terrible to you in the game. I know I strung you along but I feel you were doing it too when you said Tree was your final 2! I respect any vote you make but I’d love for you to consider giving me your vote!

Last question


What is your favorite thing about me and why

For Tatum:

but I guess my question is why should we vote for you when you got this far out of being one of the least threatening players due to inactivity?

I agree that at the beginning of the game I wasn’t as active in the house chats as much as I wanted to, BUT i was always active to people on a lower level. I feel that the fact that I was able to continue surviving votes and make it here wasn't because I was inactive because for the majority of this game I WAS active. The fact of the matter is the house had 6 chances to get me out, and chose not to. I was able to win comps to save myself AND win the most important comps to get out you who I thought was one of the biggest jury threats yet.

Nancy Thompson wrote:Carrie was I really your #1 ally after Mindy left or was I just a shield for you

Tree why should I vote for you when you didn’t have the decency to be honest with me when you turned on me? Saying you only nominated me bc of what Tatum told you when the reality is you were dropping my name to EVERYONE and were never with me even after I kept you safe on my HOH

Nancy you and Samara truly were. I felt comfortable with you to go against the Penelope/Tree/Tatum alliance. Did I want to sit in the finals with you? No. But You were one of my #1 allie’s while you were there.

Tree Gelbman wrote:

Sidney Prescott wrote:Oh Tree, there’s a lot I could ask you, and I will. This isn’t my question, but what the actually hell are you on when you say me going home was justified to our alliance? Nobody trusted you after your flip flopping.

And least closest? With 7-8 pages of game talk (if you included trying to talking to you about your vote). You’re gonna have to explain your game a LOT more specifically your train of thought with flopping on the group and evicting me if you want my vote.

Hello Sidney. I didn’t mean that you going home was justified to the alliance. What I meant was I already had plans to turn on it. But not all of you at once. Nancy told me on her HOH that you and Sheila were throwing me under the bus to her to nominate with me Penelope. I didn’t necessarily know if it was true or not BUT I ran with it. I used that to my advantage so that Tatum and Clear at least saw my reasoning for why I wanted to turn on you specifically. Not just because I wanted to do it just to do it. Is more so what I meant by that.

Me and you did talk a lot of game but I actually had WAY more pages with Sheila and Tatum believe it or not. Clear and you were about the same in page length but I trusted Clear more. I felt like she would look out for me more than you would down the line which is ultimately why you were the most expendable to me in the group. Everything sort of just fell into my lap and it was all according to plan for me. My train of thought with flipping on the group was I was becoming closer to Penelope and Mindy day by day. Also Samara and Carrie and even Nancy for that matter. I realized when jury hit that this was the perfect opportunity to push forward with a new group to take out the people perceived as the power players in the game at the time. That is why I did everything that I did.

You already had plans to turn on the alliance that kept you safe and vice versa with no logical explanation? Even knowing we were the strongest players in the game in terms of not only social ability but prowess? Can you explain to me your reasoning?

And it seems odd how you believed one lie from someone you may or may not have been working with since the jump over someone who could actually prove their loyalty to you. Very odd.

It actually seems you ran with things to avoid being the bad guy rather than an actual reason for doing so. You seemed to have no issue dumping whoever didn’t serve your immediate needs, which would be commendable only if you owned up to it.

For Mindy: I also loved every moment with you and I was SO sad to see you leave. Like I’ve mentioned, I do feel that my game was very different than Tree’s but I do deserve your vote. I was able to survive 6 times on the block, win competitions, and ensure that majority of jury didn’t hate me directly. I feel I truly played this game from day 1 and made decisions that would advance my game further on the spot. I also was able to flip my game around when you were evicted to make sure I wasn’t in that position again. I love you and respect any vote you make!

Anyways this interro— I mean line of questioning is going almost nowhere, so I’ll leave with one final question:

To the both of you, why do you deserve my vote, seeing both of you were dishonest about your vote to me, apparently had no working game relationship with me, and failed to address me in your closing speeches?

Luba Gibbs wrote:Last question


What is your favorite thing about me and why

My favorite thing about you is the fact that you are confident and are always willing to defend yourself because that’s not easy for everyone to do!

Sidney Prescott wrote:Anyways this interro— I mean line of questioning is going almost nowhere, so I’ll leave with one final question:

To the both of you, why do you deserve my vote, seeing both of you were dishonest about your vote to me, apparently had no working game relationship with me, and failed to address me in your closing speeches?

Sidney I believe I deserve your vote because I truly believe I have played a winning game. I know my flaws and what I would do different if I could go back - but I cant and I hope you can see that I still am a deserving winner. I have a lot about my game that I believe factors into me being a deserving winner.

With your vote I did lie and gave you false hope but there was strategy in there. I felt you were always going to come for me after nominating me and the fact that we just didn’t work together. I knew I needed you out. I didn’t want to risk you being upset while still having time in the house to talk to other players. I do think you would’ve been a great contender to win and I needed you out sooner rather than later but it was all because I truly feared but respected you. But at the end of the day, I had to lie.

Thank you for your answers, Carrie! (sorry I asked a lot just wanted to see if you saw the questions I asked regarding Samara and the final 2)

I’m still deciding what to do but I’m taking everything being said into consideration!

Oh forgot to ask this in my long paragraph earlier but Tree, how many comps were you throwing and were you also even throwing in the end game after your double eviction hoh/veto?

Tree, you’re claiming that you thought it was best for you to keep Thomasin during the round Rhonda left and you said it was because you thought it was best for you and you wanted to work with Thomasin…but you wanted her out the very next round or so that she got evicted… my question is, how can you say all of that when you were telling me privately that you didn’t feel good that our 5 all didn’t want her out, which was more reason for you to go for her… EYE was one of the people pushing Thomasin to make up lies to say to you so you wouldn’t gun for her and you fell for every single lie she told you. So was that decision made because you thought it was best for your game or was it because you were gullible enough to turn on Rhonda and keep Thomasin safe because of the lies she told you?

I’m leaving work now y’all. I’ll be on in like 30 to answer everything else

Hi besties im so proud of you both, I feel like a proud ghost mom watching her kids graduate high school.